Shopify vs BigCommerce in 2026: The Honest Comparison from an Agency That Builds on Both

Paid monthly, Shopify and BigCommerce cost the same to the dollar. The bills do not. Five differences decide it: what happens to your bill as you grow, wholesale and B2B, apps versus built in, how far you can bend it, and momentum. Includes the full video.

Shopify vs BigCommerce in 2026: The Honest Comparison from an Agency That Builds on Both

Shopify vs BigCommerce comes down to how you sell and how you get paid. If you sell mostly to consumers, choose Shopify. If you sell mostly through quotes and sales reps, choose BigCommerce. Paid monthly, the two charge the same price for their three main plans. The bills still come out very different, because BigCommerce puts a sales limit on every plan and Shopify does not. If you searched for BigCommerce vs Shopify instead, the answer is the same. The expensive mistakes happen between those two cases, and that is what the rest of this post covers.

This post is the written version of our video. If you'd rather watch, it's 11 minutes:

One warning first. If you compared these two a couple of years ago, a lot of what you learned is out of date. We checked the comparison articles that rank on Google. Three of them still say BigCommerce has no transaction fees. Some still say Shopify only does wholesale on its most expensive plan. Neither one is true anymore.

At IWD Agency we have been building online stores since 2008, and we build on both of these, as a Shopify Plus agency and a BigCommerce agency. We are partners with both, so we get paid either way and can tell you plainly where each one shines and where each one will cost you.

Key takeaways

  • Same price tag, different bill. Paid monthly, both charge $39, $105 and $399. BigCommerce adds a sales limit to every plan. Shopify has none.
  • "BigCommerce has no transaction fees" is out of date. Since June 2026 the fee is $0 only with 21 listed payment providers. Otherwise it is 2%, 1% or 0.6% by plan, including on purchase orders.
  • "Shopify B2B needs Plus" is out of date too. Since April 2026, company accounts, payment terms and volume pricing are on the regular plans, with up to three wholesale catalogs.
  • BigCommerce B2B Edition goes deeper, with quotes and an invoice portal. It is an add-on sold through sales, with no public price.
  • Momentum favors Shopify. Store Leads counts about 3.3 million live Shopify stores, up 15% in a year, against about 36,000 for BigCommerce, down 10%.
  • Before you sign with either one, ask for your bill in writing at double your current revenue.

What Shopify and BigCommerce share

Both are hosted, so they run the servers, the security and the updates.

If you pay monthly, the price tags match to the dollar. Pay yearly, and BigCommerce is cheaper on the two bigger plans.

TierShopify planShopify sales limitBigCommerce planBigCommerce sales limit
EntryBasic: $39 a month ($29 paid yearly)NoneCore: $39 a month ($29 paid yearly)$30K a year, then moved up to Growth
MiddleGrow: $105 a month ($89 paid yearly)NoneGrowth: $105 a month ($79 paid yearly)$100K a year, then moved up to Scale
UpperAdvanced: $399 a month ($359 paid yearly)NoneScale: $399 a month ($299 paid yearly)0.9% on sales above $33,333 a month. Moved to Performance at $2M a year
EnterprisePlus: from $2,300 a month on a 3-year term, $2,500 on a 1-year termNone published. Shopify says a variable fee might applyPerformance: from $1,499 a month, billed yearlyDefault of $250K a month, then 0.6%. Set by contract

Prices are in US dollars, from each company's own pricing pages in November 2026. BigCommerce renamed its plans on June 1, 2026, so older articles use different names.

So if the price tag is the same, why are the bills so different? There are five differences that matter.

Shopify vs BigCommerce: the 5 differences that matter

1. What happens to your bill as you grow

Shopify does not care how much you sell. You can do $50,000 a year or $5 million on the same plan. You move up when you want the features.

BigCommerce puts a sales limit on every plan. Pass it, and you either move up a plan or pay a fee. Picture a landlord who raises your rent every time you get a raise.

BigCommerce measures sales over the trailing 12 months, as order value including tax and shipping, minus 10%. Marketplace, manual and API orders count too.

Here is what that looks like in practice:

  • Pass about $110,000 a year, and BigCommerce moves you to the $399 plan. On Shopify, you could still be on $39.
  • Past about $450,000 a year, BigCommerce adds a fee of 0.9% on the sales above that line. It is measured monthly, so one big month can trigger it. At $1 million a year, that is about $4,500 on top of the plan. At $2 million, it is more than $12,000.
  • At $2 million of counted sales, BigCommerce moves you to Performance, its enterprise plan. You don't get a vote.

This table shows what the platform itself costs at each revenue level.

Online sales a yearShopify planShopify, per yearBigCommerce planBigCommerce, per year
$25KBasic$468Core$468
$60KBasic$468Growth (over the $30K limit)$1,260
$120KBasic or Grow$468 to $1,260Scale (over the $100K limit)$4,788
$500KGrow or Advanced$1,260 to $4,788Scale + 0.9% over the limit$5,238
$1MAdvanced$4,788Scale + 0.9% over the limit$9,288
$2MAdvanced$4,788Scale + 0.9% over the limit$17,388
$2.5MAdvanced, or Plus from $27,600$4,788 or $27,600+Performance (moved at $2M)from $17,988
$5MAdvanced, or Plus from $27,600$4,788 or $27,600+Performance + 0.6% over the default limitabout $27,000

This is our own math from the published rules: list prices paid monthly, plus any charge tied to sales volume. It assumes Shopify Payments on Shopify and a listed provider on BigCommerce, and leaves out card processing, apps, themes and build cost. The Shopify plan shown is our read of what a store that size typically picks. The enterprise rows are starting prices.

To be fair, BigCommerce's enterprise plan starts lower than Shopify Plus. Both can add a fee on revenue at high volume, and both negotiate, so get both quotes.

Then there are payment fees. Both platforms waive their own fee if you use a payment provider they like. Go outside the list on either one, and you pay up to 2% on top of what your card processor charges.

QuestionShopifyBigCommerce
Fee waived when you useShopify Payments (one provider)21 listed providers, including Stripe, PayPal, Adyen, Klarna and Worldpay
Fee with any other provider2% Basic, 1% Grow, 0.6% Advanced, 0.2% Plus2% Core, 1% Growth, 0.6% Scale, 0% on a Performance contract
Card rate, online2.9%, 2.7%, 2.5% or 2.25% + 30¢ by plan on Shopify Payments. Premium cards cost moreFrom 2.89% + 29¢. Per-plan rates are no longer published

So BigCommerce gives you more freedom on payments. Authorize.net and Square were not on its list when we checked, though. As a worked example, $2 million a year through an outside gateway costs 0.6% on either upper plan: about $12,000 on Shopify Advanced, and about $10,800 on BigCommerce Scale after its 10% reduction.

Here is the trap if you take purchase orders on BigCommerce. A customer sends you a $20,000 order and pays by check. There is no card and no processor. On the Scale plan, you are still billed about $108 for it, which is 0.6% of the counted order value. Do $1 million a year that way, and it is about $5,400. BigCommerce's pricing update says the fee covers manual and offline payment methods. A Performance contract drops it. Whichever platform you are considering, ask in writing how offline orders are billed.

We built a free spreadsheet for exactly this math. The Platform Comparison and ROI Calculator compares total cost over several years with your own numbers.

2. Wholesale and B2B

This is where the old advice is most wrong.

Shopify used to keep its B2B features on Shopify Plus. Since April 2026 they are on the regular plans too. Company accounts, payment terms, volume pricing and quick order are included at no extra cost. Think of it as a wholesale counter built into your store.

It has limits. On the regular plans you get up to three wholesale catalogs. If every customer needs their own negotiated pricing, that is Shopify Plus. BigCommerce does the same thing: its price lists sit on the Performance plan. Quotes on Shopify run through draft orders or an app, and we haven't found built-in approval steps for your buyers.

BigCommerce goes the other way. It sells B2B Edition as an add-on, through its sales team. There is no public price, and BigCommerce does not publish which plans can buy it, so ask which plan you would need. It is less of a counter and more of a whole sales office: reps log in as the customer, buyers request quotes, and there is a portal for paying invoices.

B2B capabilityShopify Basic, Grow, AdvancedShopify PlusBigCommerce Core, Growth, ScaleBigCommerce with B2B Edition
Company accounts and locationsIncludedIncludedCustomer groups only, from GrowthIncluded, with parent and child companies
Wholesale price listsUp to 3 catalogs, set per marketUnlimited, per customerGroup discounts only. No price listsPrice lists, no stated limit
Quick order by SKUIncludedIncludedAppQuick order pad, with CSV upload
QuotesDraft orders or an appDraft orders or an appAppBuyer requests a quote, rep prices it, quote becomes an order
Purchase approvalsNot built inNot built inNoOne step, on shared shopping lists
Sales rep orders for a customerGrow and up, through draft ordersThrough draft ordersNoRep logs in as the customer
Payment terms (net 30 and similar)IncludedIncludedNoPer company
Invoice portalNo portalNo portalNoBuyers view and pay invoices, including part payments
Deposits and part payments at checkoutNoIncludedNoThrough invoices
How B2B is soldIn the plan, no extra costIn the plan, no extra costNot available as B2B EditionAdd-on through sales, no public price

Sources: Shopify's B2B plan features table and BigCommerce's B2B Edition help guides, both read in November 2026.

So if you are a brand adding a wholesale channel, Shopify is now good enough that you can probably stay put. If quotes and sales reps are how you sell, BigCommerce is the stronger starting point.

If your buyers order through their own procurement systems, our punchout catalog guide covers the options on each platform. And if you are comparing more than these two for B2B, read Shopify vs Magento for B2B next.

Already trying to place yourself? Our free platform quiz asks how you sell, how you price, what your checkout needs and what systems you run. In about five minutes it gives you a shortlist of three platforms.

3. Apps versus built in

Shopify's answer to almost anything is an app. Its app store lists more than 16,000 of them. BigCommerce has over 1,200. The catch is the same as with streaming services. Each one is cheap, and then one day you add them up. Five apps at $30 a month each is $1,800 a year, and in our experience Shopify stores often carry dozens of paid apps.

BigCommerce builds more into the platform. Product reviews, more than 70 discount types, live shipping quotes and staff logins come with every plan. On Shopify's $39 plan, staff logins aren't included. It's just you. Grow includes 5 and Advanced includes 15.

Read the fine print on both sides, though:

  • Product filters. On BigCommerce they don't show up until the $399 Scale plan. Abandoned cart recovery and customer groups start on Growth.
  • Variants have flipped. Shopify now allows 2,048 variants per product, against 600 on BigCommerce. Shopify still caps you at three options, like size, color and material. BigCommerce allows 250 values per option.
  • Point of sale. Shopify has its own point of sale for physical stores. BigCommerce connects to other companies' systems, such as Square and Clover.

4. How far you can bend it

Checkout. On Shopify, you can repaint the checkout on any plan. You can only remodel it on Shopify Plus, where the information, shipping and payment steps open up. BigCommerce's checkout is open source, so your developers can rebuild it.

Several brands. BigCommerce runs up to eight storefronts from one back end, for $30, $50 or $100 a month each depending on the plan. On Shopify, a separate brand usually means a separate store and a separate subscription. Shopify Plus includes nine extra stores, but they have to belong to the same brand.

Headless storefronts. Both have their own framework. Shopify has Hydrogen, with Oxygen hosting at no extra charge on paid plans. BigCommerce has Catalyst, which is open source, built on Next.js and can be hosted anywhere. Our headless commerce guide goes deeper.

API limits. If you are connecting an ERP, ask both of them about API limits. That is the speed limit on how fast your systems can talk to the store. Shopify's regular plans allow 2 to 4 calls a second on its older REST API, and Plus allows 20. BigCommerce allows 150 calls every 30 seconds on Core and Growth and 450 on Scale, with no published cap on eligible Performance plans. On both platforms, the fast lane is on the top plan. Nobody reads that page until the overnight inventory sync finishes at lunch. If NetSuite is your ERP, our sister company's Dominate NetSuite Shopify connector is built for that sync.

5. Momentum

Nobody likes to talk about this one.

According to Store Leads, an independent tracker, Shopify runs about 3.3 million live stores (3,298,869 on November 13, 2026), up 15% in a year. BigCommerce runs about 36,000 (36,019), down 10%. In the last 90 days, Store Leads counted 318 stores moving from BigCommerce to Shopify and 116 moving the other way. That is almost three to one.

Why should you care? More stores means more apps, more developers, and more people who have already solved your exact problem.

Smaller doesn't mean worse, though. BigCommerce's parent company reported that sales through its stores rose 14% from a year ago in the third quarter of 2026, even while the company's own revenue dipped 2.1%. Fewer stores, and bigger ones.

The analysts split the same way. In Gartner's 2026 Magic Quadrant for digital commerce, Shopify is a Leader and BigCommerce is a Challenger. In this year's Paradigm B2B Combine, which grades B2B platforms for mid-size companies, BigCommerce won a medal in all 12 categories, 10 of them gold. Both results are as reported by the vendors, since the full reports are paywalled. BigCommerce is a specialist now.

On speed, independent data gives Shopify the edge. In the HTTP Archive's technology report for October 2026, which uses real Chrome visits, 76.5% of Shopify sites passed Google's Core Web Vitals on mobile, against 64.4% of BigCommerce sites. BigCommerce actually wins on responsiveness (96.7% against 85.9%) and loses on layout shift and server response. Either one can be fast with a good build.

BigCommerce vs Shopify: the whole comparison on one screen

ShopifyBigCommerce
Main plans, paid monthly$39, $105, $399$39, $105, $399
Enterprise planPlus, from $2,300 a month on a 3-year termPerformance, from $1,499 a month, billed yearly
Sales limitsNone$30K and $100K a year, then 0.9% above $33,333 a month on Scale
Platform fee on payments$0 with Shopify Payments, otherwise 0.2% to 2%$0 with 21 listed providers, otherwise 0.6% to 2% on Core, Growth and Scale
B2BBuilt into every plan. Up to 3 catalogs below PlusB2B Edition add-on with quotes and an invoice portal, sold through sales
App storeMore than 16,000 appsOver 1,200 apps
Variants per product2,048, with 3 options600, with 250 values per option
CheckoutBasic changes on all plans. Full control on PlusOpen source
Several storefrontsSeparate storesOne back end, $30 to $100 a month each
Live stores (Store Leads)About 3.3 million, up 15%About 36,000, down 10%
Passing Core Web Vitals on mobile (HTTP Archive)76.5%64.4%
Best fitConsumer brands, and brands adding wholesaleB2B sold through quotes, reps and invoices

Which one is right for you?

Notice something. Neither one is the cheap one, and neither one is the expensive one. It comes down to how you sell and how you get paid.

Choose Shopify if:

  • You sell mostly direct to consumers
  • You are a brand adding wholesale on the side
  • Your team is small and you want the easiest admin and the biggest app store
  • You are happy on Shopify Payments

If that's you, look at our Shopify development services and Shopify web design work, or read the Shopify Plus migration guide.

Choose BigCommerce if:

  • B2B is the business, with quotes, sales reps and invoices
  • Your payment provider is on BigCommerce's list, and Shopify would charge you extra for it
  • You run several storefronts off one catalog
  • Your developers want control of the checkout

If that's you, start with our BigCommerce development services or our BigCommerce headless page.

When neither one is the right fit

If your pricing has to come live from your ERP, or you need several layers of approvals, neither one may be the right fit. That is a different conversation. Our Shopify vs Magento for B2B post covers what changes when you control the code, and Adobe Commerce vs BigCommerce for B2B covers the next step up from BigCommerce.

One tip before you sign

Before you sign with either one, ask for your bill in writing at double your current revenue. The plan, the sales limits, the payment fees, all of it.

A written number at twice your size tells you what growth will cost before you have built anything.

Frequently asked questions

Is BigCommerce cheaper than Shopify?

It depends on how much you sell. Paid monthly, the three main plans cost the same: $39, $105 and $399. Paid yearly, BigCommerce is cheaper on the two bigger plans, and its enterprise plan starts lower than Shopify Plus. But BigCommerce moves you up a plan at $30,000 and $100,000 in yearly sales, and adds 0.9% above $33,333 a month on Scale. At $1 million a year, by our math, the platform costs about $9,288 on BigCommerce against $4,788 on Shopify Advanced.

Does BigCommerce charge transaction fees?

Yes, since June 1, 2026, on some orders. The fee is $0 when the order goes through one of 21 listed payment providers, including Stripe, PayPal and Adyen. With any other provider it is 2% on Core, 1% on Growth and 0.6% on Scale. It also applies to offline orders such as purchase orders. A Performance contract removes it.

Does Shopify charge transaction fees?

Only if you don't use Shopify Payments. With an outside payment provider, Shopify charges 2% on Basic, 1% on Grow, 0.6% on Advanced and 0.2% on Plus, on top of what your card processor charges.

Does Shopify do B2B without Plus?

Yes. Since April 2026, company accounts, payment terms, quantity rules, volume pricing and quick order are on the Basic, Grow and Advanced plans at no extra cost. Those plans are limited to three wholesale catalogs. Unlimited catalogs, a catalog assigned to a single company, deposits and part payments still require Shopify Plus.

Which is better for B2B, Shopify or BigCommerce?

If you are a brand adding a wholesale channel, Shopify's built-in B2B is usually enough. If quotes, sales reps and invoices are how you sell, BigCommerce with B2B Edition is the stronger starting point. It adds quote requests, an invoice portal and reps who can log in as the customer. It is an add-on sold through BigCommerce's sales team, with no public price.

Which is better for SEO, Shopify or BigCommerce?

Both are fine with a good build. The clearest independent difference is speed. In the HTTP Archive's October 2026 data, 76.5% of Shopify sites passed Google's Core Web Vitals on mobile, against 64.4% of BigCommerce sites. BigCommerce scored better on responsiveness. Your theme, your apps and your content matter more than the platform. Our guide to which ecommerce platform is best for SEO goes deeper.

What happened to BigCommerce?

Three things changed. The parent company renamed itself Commerce, and it also owns Feedonomics and Makeswift. On June 1, 2026, BigCommerce renamed its plans to Core, Growth, Scale and Performance, lowered the sales limits on the two entry plans and added a fee on orders paid outside its listed providers. And its store count fell about 10% in a year, according to Store Leads. In the third quarter of 2026, Commerce reported revenue of $84.2 million, down 2.1% from a year earlier, while sales through its stores rose 14%. The platform is still developed and supported, and we still build on it as a BigCommerce partner.

Can I migrate between Shopify and BigCommerce?

Yes, in either direction. The work depends on your catalog, your customer accounts, your integrations and how much of the checkout is custom, so we scope a migration against your store and quote it before any work starts.

Not sure which one fits? Book a 30-minute assessment

Both are good platforms. The right one depends on how you sell. If you'd like a second opinion, book a 30-minute assessment. Bring your yearly online revenue, your catalog size and the systems you need to connect. We'll tell you which way we'd go, and why.

If you're not ready for a call, start with the free platform quiz and the cost comparison spreadsheet.